Just Plain Pickled to Death Read online

  Table of Contents

  Just Plain Pickled to Death

  Copyright

  Dedication

  Acknowledgements

  Chapter One

  Chapter Two

  Chapter Three

  Chapter Four

  Chapter Five

  Magdalena Yoder’s Wedding Feast, from Soup to Nuts

  Great-Granny Yoder’s Onion Cheese Soup

  Chapter Six

  Chapter Seven

  Chapter Eight

  Chapter Nine

  Chapter Ten

  Magdalena Yoder’s Wedding Feast, from Soup to Nuts

  Freni Hostetler’s Wilted Dandelion Salad

  Chapter Eleven

  Chapter Twelve

  Chapter Thirteen

  Chapter Fourteen

  Chapter Fifteen

  Magdalena Yoder’s Wedding Feast, from Soup to Nuts

  Auntie Leah’s Pork Chops with Sauerkraut und Apples

  Chapter Sixteen

  Chapter Seventeen

  Chapter Eighteen

  Chapter Nineteen

  Chapter Twenty

  Magdalena Yoder’s Wedding Feast, from Soup to Nuts

  Auntie Magdalena’s Potato Dumplings

  Chapter Twenty-one

  Chapter Twenty-two

  Chapter Twenty-three

  Chapter Twenty-Four

  Chapter Twenty-five

  Magdalena Yoder’s Wedding Feast, from Soup to Nuts

  Auntie Lizzie’s Mushroom and Pea Casserole

  Chapter Twenty-six

  Chapter Twenty-seven

  Chapter Twenty-eight

  Chapter Twenty-nine

  Chapter Thirty

  Magdalena Yoder’s Wedding Feast, from Soup to Nuts

  Barbara Hostetler’s Save-the-Day Pecan Pies

  Discover Tamar Myers

  About the Author

  Just Plain Pickled to Death

  An Amish Bed and Breakfast Mystery with Recipes #4

  Tamar Myers

  Copyright

  This e-book is licensed to you for your personal enjoyment only.

  This e-book may not be sold, shared, or given away.

  This is a work of fiction. Names, characters, places, and incidents are either products of the writer’s imagination or are used fictitiously and are not to be construed as real. Any resemblance to actual events, locales, organizations, or persons, living or dead, is entirely coincidental.

  Just Plain Pickled to Death

  Copyright © Tamar Myers, 1997

  Ebook ISBN: 9781625173355

  ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

  No part of this work may be used, reproduced, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, without prior permission in writing from the publisher, except in the case of brief quotations embodied in critical articles or reviews.

  NYLA Publishing

  350 7th Avenue, Suite 2003, NY 10001, New York.

  http://www.nyliterary.com

  Dedication

  For Joseph Pittman, Senior Editor at Dutton Signet

  Acknowledgements

  I would like to acknowledge Eben Weiss, Assistant Editor at Dutton Signet, as well as the behind-the-scenes players there who are an in-valuable part of the team. Special thanks goes to Tom Longshaw of Rock Hill, who helped me when I was in a pickle. In addition, I would like to thank the Blue Stocking Club of Pittsburgh (“younz” are great), and the Blue Stocking Book Club of Rock Hill, South Carolina (thanks, y’all for the support).

  Chapter One

  Sarah Weaver was found dead in a barrel of pickled sauerkraut. On my back porch. Freni, who found her, screamed, fainted, and then screamed again. I merely fainted.

  Aaron Miller, my fiance, slapped me gently back to consciousness.

  “It’s okay,” he said. ‘‘Susannah is calling the police.”

  I raised up on one elbow and eyed the barrel balefully. “It’s not okay,” I wailed. “It’s horrible!”

  “What I meant is that the authorities have been called. It’s still horrible about the body.”

  What I meant was that a perfectly good barrel of sauerkraut had been ruined, and I would be hard-pressed to find a replacement in time for my wedding supper just a week away. That was my gut reaction, but of course I didn’t say that. Please don’t get me wrong, it was horrible about the woman in the barrel too, but she was obviously very dead and there was nothing to be done about that now. Besides which, if that was who I thought it was, she had been missing for almost twenty years.

  “Ooooh,” Freni moaned. “Ooooh.”

  Aaron left my side to attend to my elderly cousin.

  I got up on all fours, then on my knees, and took another quick peek at the woman I thought was Sarah Weaver. It was a morbid thing to do, but I felt strangely compelled. Besides which, somebody needed to make a positive identification.

  As far as I could tell, it was her all right. Same long blond hair, same cheap plastic hair bands, same awful paisley dress. Still, pickling is not kind to one’s features, and an autopsy was no doubt in order just to be a hundred percent sure.

  A wave of nausea hit me like a ton of bricks, and I lay back down again and closed my eyes. I tried focusing on my special spot, which is a pond just across the road from my farm. That worked for a while, and although I could still hear Aaron’s calm voice as he tried to soothe Freni, I was at least able to shut the picture of Sarah with sauerkraut in her hair out of my mind. At least until my sister, Susannah, came back.

  “I called Melvin,” she said, sounding just as normal as could be. “He and Zelda will be right over. He said not to touch anything. Especially not to eat any of the kraut, on account it might not be good anymore.”

  A second wave of nausea hit me. “Call Doc Shafor,” I managed to say through clenched teeth.

  “Ah, do I have to?”

  I pounded the porch floor with a fist, which Susannah correctly interpreted as a command. She left whining, and I lay still for a few minutes before crawling off into the house to collect my thoughts. That took several minutes more.

  Sarah Weaver, I remembered, was not the only member of her family to go missing for two decades.

  Her mother, Rebecca Weaver, had disappeared approximately a month before her daughter had. Perhaps she was in that barrel as well. I forced myself to glance at the barrel again. No, Sarah’s mother couldn’t possibly be sharing the same slatted coffin. There simply wasn’t enough room. At least she hadn’t shown up on my back porch the week of my wedding.

  I started to breathe a sigh of relief, and then I remembered something else. It was obvious that Aaron hadn’t recognized Sarah. Perhaps he should have. Aaron and Sarah were first cousins, after all. Sarah’s mother, Rebecca—the first to go missing—was Aaron’s aunt, his father’s sister. But in all fairness, Aaron had left Hernia, Pennsylvania, when his cousin was only nine or ten.

  I’m afraid that now is the time to confess that the reason my fiance left home was to join the army. That was in 1972, and the Vietnam War was still in progress. The very fact that Aaron volunteered to fight in a war literally broke his parents’ hearts. His mother actually died the following year.

  You see, Aaron and Sarah, like my sister, Susannah, and I, were raised Amish-Mennonites. Our pacifist roots go back to 1536, to a man named Menno Simons (from whom we get the word “Mennonite”). They were slightly modified in 1693 by a man named Jakob Amman (from whom we get the word “Amish”) and brought to this country in 1738 by our ancestor Jacob Hochstetler and his contemporaries. My particular branch of the family tree curved back on itself and became Mennonite again, while other closely related branches remained staunchly Amish.

  From this b
rief description of my ancestors you may extrapolate two things. The first is that despite their resistance to military service, the Mennonites, Amish, and Amish-Mennonites are longtime Americans and loyal to the core. The second is that my forebears are more interbred than pedigreed poodles, and only slightly less interbred than the royal families of Europe. To put it bluntly, I am my own cousin. Several times over.

  The upshot is that Aaron and I are somehow cousins, but not so closely related that we can’t be legally married. Of course, Sarah Weaver—the unfortunate young woman in the sauerkraut barrel—was some sort of a cousin to me as well, but she was Aaron’s first cousin. I was going to have to tell him that, since he obviously didn’t remember her.

  Aaron would undoubtedly be stunned at first, but he hadn’t known his cousin well enough to be grief-stricken. Susannah had. Sarah and Susannah had been best girlhood friends until that tragic day—it was around the Fourth of July, if I remember right— when Sarah Weaver disappeared. Her disappearance had rocked the town of Hernia and, indeed, a large portion of the state. A massive hunt, involving dogs and even the FBI, ensued, but of course the girl had never been found. For some reason my sister’s mind had been unable to cope with the loss of her best friend, and so she simply didn’t. That’s what it seemed like, at any rate. One day Sarah and Susannah were giggling about boys, and the next day Susannah was giggling alone. It was as if Sarah had never existed.

  Mennonites of our ilk don’t put much stock in psychotherapy—we rely on the Bible instead—but even that wasn’t enough to make Susannah face reality.

  Unfortunately, my poor sister might have to face the truth in just a matter of minutes because Melvin, our chief of police, had all the sensitivity of a bull in heat, and Melvin would undoubtedly recognize Sarah. The two of them had once dated in high school.

  I found Susannah waiting on the front porch for Melvin and Zelda to show up. Susannah had dated Melvin too—much more recently, in fact—but even though she no longer cared an owl’s hoot for him, she couldn’t stand to see him “in the clutches of Zelda.”

  “You all right?” I asked, sitting down next to her, on an Adirondack rocker.

  “Fine,” Susannah said impatiently, “but when that damn bitch gets here, I’m going to give her what for. Last time I saw her she was wearing a sweater I left in Melvin’s car.”

  I hoped the sweater was cardigan and meant to be shed. My sister, despite her strict upbringing, has all the morals of the aforementioned bull in heat. She is ten years my junior, and when our parents died an untimely death in the Allegheny Tunnel, they inadvertently heaped a lot on my plate. Not only was I suddenly responsible for a very irresponsible sibling, but I was the owner of a farm as well. I was good at managing neither, and my sister ended up marrying and then divorcing a Presbyterian! The farm was downsized considerably and eventually became a very successful inn—the PennDutch—with a list of highfalutin clients like you wouldn’t believe. Some of them are so highfalutin, in fact, that they have only first names.

  “Susannah, dear,” I said patiently, despite the fact that I don’t tolerate swearing in my presence, “there is something I need to tell you before Melvin and Zelda get here.”

  “If you mean that story going around about the two of them getting married this fall, well, don’t believe it. Melvin would rather read a book than marry her.”

  That described Melvin perfectly. The man would have you believe he’s an animated version of the Encyclopaedia Britannica, but the only covers he’s cracked are the ones on his bed. His arrogance is surpassed only by his stupidity. I know, it is unkind of me to talk this way, but how else can I describe a grown man who once mailed a gallon of ice cream—by UPS—to a favorite relative in another state?

  “This has nothing to do with Melvin and Zelda, dear. It has to do with you. You and Sarah Weaver.”

  Susan’s face had turned to stone. I knew she could no longer hear me, but I had to continue.

  “I think that’s Sarah Weaver back there,” I said gently.

  She said nothing. It was time to try another tack.

  “You saw the girl in the barrel. Who do you think it is?”

  Susannah and her stone face hopped off the porch and disappeared down Hertzler Lane just minutes before Melvin and Zelda arrived. I was tempted to go after her, but I know my sister, and I knew that she would be all right—in a manner of speaking. Sarah Weaver, and the barrel of kraut, had been left far behind.

  Chapter Two

  I barely had time to tell Aaron that Sarah was his cousin before Melvin and Zelda came screeching up in a pathetic portrayal of proper police procedure. There was no need for them to have the siren wailing and the lights flashing, and there was certainly no need for them to jump out of the car with their guns drawn. Whoever killed Sarah Weaver had long since departed the scene, if not the earth.

  “Put those things away,” I chided them, and rightfully so. Both of them are distant kin as well, which means they have Amish forebears and therefore have no business handling weapons of any sort in the first place. Beyond that, anything in Melvin’s hands makes him armed and dangerous. He almost put out his own eye with a weenie-roasting stick when we were kids, and it had a hot dog firmly attached to the end.

  “Police business,” Melvin said brusquely and tried to brush me aside.

  I blocked his way.

  “Just hold your horses, buster. The body in the barrel isn’t going anywhere, and neither is the person who put her there.”

  “Oh, yeah? Says who?”

  “Says me.”

  Melvin’s left eye rotated slowly in its socket until it fixed on the right side of my face.

  “Just who the hell do you think you are?”

  “Magdalena Portulaca Yoder. I have brown hair, blue eyes, and am on the tall side. My current weight is none of your business. Neither is my age, except that you have it written down somewhere and you always get it wrong. I’m forty-four years old, Melvin, not fifty-four.”

  He made another unsuccessful attempt to stare at me. Melvin has bulging eyes that operate independently of each other, only one of several features that make him look like a giant praying mantis. Freni claims that Melvin was kicked in the head by a bull he tried to milk, which would explain one of the concave curves of his face. Others have told me that story as well. Personally, I’m inclined to believe that what you see is what you get. More than once I’ve come real close to pointing a can of Raid at Melvin to see his reaction.

  “Move aside, Yoder!”

  “Not until you put those awful guns away and hear me out.”

  “Aha! So you’re obstructing justice, are you?”

  Zelda stepped between the two of us. “We are just trying to do our job, Magdalena.”

  I looked over her head to Melvin. Now the right eye had locked in on the left side of my face, which is just as well, because it is my more flattering side.

  “I have no interest in obstructing justice, Melvin. In fact, I have some information that may well speed up the process.”

  “Is this a confession?”

  I prayed silently for patience to deal with Melvin. While I was at it, I prayed that I would win the Publishers Clearing House Sweepstakes. So far, neither prayer has been answered.

  “I’ll take your silence as a yes,” Melvin sneered. “And don’t think it comes as a surprise. You always were a violent one, Magdalena.”

  I took a solid step forward, forcing little Zelda to duck out of the way.

  “You take that back, buster!”

  I don’t remember actually touching Melvin. I concede that I may have given him a gentle rap or two on the chest with my knuckles, but I certainly didn’t mean him any bodily harm.

  “Aha! Now it’s assault!”

  I stepped back. “What?”

  There was a triumphant gleam in his eyes. Well, the right one, at any rate.

  “You just added ‘assaulting an officer’ to the charges.”

  “What!”

&n
bsp; “And you needn’t shout, unless you want ‘disturbing the peace’ added to the list.”

  “It’s Sarah Weaver,” I screamed. “She’s the one Freni found in the barrel of kraut on my back porch, and by the look of things, she’s been in there an awfully long time. Probably since the day she went missing!”

  Melvin’s eyes jerked into temporary alignment. “My Sarah Weaver? The one I dated in high school?”

  “The very one. And it was only one date, dear,” I pointed out kindly. To have heard Sarah back then, it was one date too many.

  “Sarah was never good enough for you anyway,” Zelda muttered. To be truthful, I couldn’t hear all the words clearly, but I’m sure that’s the gist of what she said. Zelda Root not only has the hots for her boss, Melvin, but it’s common knowledge that she is intensely jealous of anyone who normally sits down to micturate. No one in the community can convince her that—at least in this case—jealousy is a wasted emotion.

  It was the left eye now, fixed on my nose. “You didn’t like Sarah Weaver much, did you, Magdalena?”

  “I liked her just fine.” It was the truth. In fact, I probably liked her better than I did my sister back then.

  “It’s one thing not to like someone, Magdalena, but murder?”

  “I did not murder Sarah Weaver!”

  “Well, somebody did.” Zelda had the irritating habit of butting into all my important conversations. “Teenage girls don’t climb into sauerkraut barrels of their own accord.”

  “Well, even if this one did, she didn’t do it on my back porch. That barrel was delivered just this morning.”

  “Oh?” They both said. They both sounded disappointed as well.

  “That’s right. Aaron Miller—my fiance—delivered that this morning. It was a wedding present from his father.”