The Hand That Rocks the Ladle Read online

  The Hand that Rocks the Ladle

  An Amish Bed and Breakfast Mystery with Recipes

  Tamar Myers

  Copyright

  This ebook is licensed to you for your personal enjoyment only.

  This ebook may not be sold, shared, or given away.

  This is a work of fiction. Names, characters, places, and incidents are either products of the writer’s imagination or are used fictitiously and are not to be construed as real. Any resemblance to actual events, locales, organizations, or persons, living or dead, is entirely coincidental.

  The Hand that Rocks the Ladle

  Copyright © Tamar Myers, 2000

  Ebook ISBN: 9781943772933

  ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

  No part of this work may be used, reproduced, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, without prior permission in writing from the publisher, except in the case of brief quotations embodied in critical articles or reviews.

  NYLA Publishing

  350 7th Avenue, Suite 2003, NY 10001, New York.

  http://www.nyliterary.com

  Dedicated to

  Carolyn Yost

  Marilyn Memmer

  Evelyn Moler

  One

  Amish men rarely get pregnant. Elderly Amish men almost never do. Mose Hostetler, however, seemed to be the exception.

  When Freni first told me the news, I had to stifle my impulse to laugh. “What do you mean Mose is going to have a baby?”

  “Not just one baby, Magdalena, but three. My Mose is going to have triplets.”

  “Freni, dear,” I said gently, “it’s your daughter-in-law, Barbara, who is going to have triplets. Mose is going to have a nice long vacation.”

  Freni Hostetler, Mose’s wife, flapped her arms like a rooster about to crow. “Yah, Barbara is having triplets, but so is my Mose. I could feel the babies—all three of them.”

  “Where?”

  She clutched her own apron-clad abdomen. “Here. I could feel them kick.”

  I rolled my eyes and prayed for patience. I also promised myself I wouldn’t worry needlessly about my cook and her husband.

  That was three months ago, and my eyes had put on more miles than a roller derby. As for the patience, it never did come. How can one be patient with a seventy-three-year-old man who claims to have morning sickness? All that talk about hemorrhoids and constipation was enough to put me off my feed. I must have lost ten pounds, while the grandfather-to-be gained twenty. Thank heavens Amish law forbids men to dress in women’s clothes; Mose in a maternity smock is a sight these eyes never want to see. And of course, I worried.

  I couldn’t help worrying about Freni and Mose. Ever since my parents’ tragic death eleven years ago in a tunnel—squished between a milk tanker and a semi loaded to the gills with state-of-the-art running shoes—the two have been like parents to me. Who knows, by some strange genetic quirk, they might even be my parents. You see, the Hostetlers are Amish, and I am a Mennonite of Amish descent. Our families have been intermarrying for hundreds of years. Mose and Freni are distant cousins to each other, as well as to me. It would take a professional genealogist to sort out our exact relationships. Suffice it to say, our bloodlines are so tangled that I am, in fact, my own cousin. If I’m in the mood for a family picnic, all I need to do is make a sandwich.

  But a body can do only so much worrying, and as the months dragged by, I threw myself into my work like never before. I am the owner and proprietress of the PennDutch Inn in the sleepy little hamlet of Hernia, Pennsylvania. It has been said, by others than myself, that mine is the finest full-board inn west of the Alleghenies. I like to think that is because of my personal touch, and because of A.L.P.O.

  “A.L.P.O.,” I said to my new guest, “stands for Amish Lifestyle Plan Option. For an extra twenty dollars a day I’ll let you make your own bed and clean your own room. For an extra thirty dollars you get to help in the kitchen.”

  The guest stared at me from beneath eyebrows the size of feather dusters. For the record, I have never seen eyes that pale. They were gray, but so thinly pigmented that a myriad of veins showed through, causing the impression of pink.

  “Surely you jest,” he said.

  “Not at all. It says here on your registration form that you’re here to study the Amish. What better way than to immerse yourself in their way of life.”

  “What better way for you to enrich your coffer.” Coffer? I glanced at the form again. Ah, yes, the man was a professor of sociology. That would explain the somewhat shabby suit, the snagged polyester tie, and the extravagant vocabulary.

  I sighed. There is no point in trying to fleece an academic—not that I would try to do such a thing mind you. I am a good Christian woman, after all. What I mean is, in my experience, educators tend to be as tightfisted as dead boxers. Of course, it is because they are underpaid. I understand that. Still, I would be lucky if I didn’t end up owing him at the end of his stay.

  “Mr. Barnes, your room—”

  “That’s Doctor.”

  “I beg your pardon?”

  “My title is Dr. Barnes. Don’t you see the Ph.D. after my name?”

  “Of course I see it,” I said pleasantly. “What about it?”

  Watery eyes regarded me unwaveringly. “I must insist that you address me as Dr. Barnes.”

  I smiled. “I must insist that you address me as Proprietress.”

  “That’s preposterous.”

  “Tit for tat,” I said calmly. “I won’t stand on ceremony if you won’t.”

  Feather-duster eyebrows converged into one enormous thicket. “Just show me to my room, Proprietress.” I led him up the impossibly steep stairs to the guest rooms. (Yes, I do have an elevator, but why waste electricity?) If pressed, I will admit that for one split second I had the wicked urge to give him a slight push backward with the heel of my foot. Of course I wouldn’t really do such a thing. A woman guest already met her demise at the base of those stairs, and let me tell you this, there is nothing that can be done about a dent in a hardwood floor.

  But I digress. The point is, my guest lineup for that first week of October had not gotten off to a good start. And either I was coming down with a touch of arthritis, or I could feel trouble in my bones. It was not going to be a good week.

  Two

  Perhaps I should introduce myself. My full name is Magdalena Portulaca Yoder. I stand five feet ten in my bare feet, have been accused of being thin, and have a negative chest profile. I have a large head, and unkind people have suggested that my elongated proboscis would make a good cheese-cutting implement. As stated before, I am an orphan—albeit a middle-aged orphan. I have one sister, Susannah Yoder Entwhistle Stoltzfus, and since I don’t count the miniature dog she carries around in her bra as blood kin, I have no nephews (a fact she disputes). I would describe myself as fair-minded and reasonably tolerant of other folks’ proclivities.

  Thank heavens, however, my next two guests were as down to earth as plowshares. Hailing from Indiana, the Redigers were perhaps in their mid-thirties, and the epitome of wholesomeness. Neither had any extraneous initials attached to their name, and they listed their occupations as carpenter and housewife respectively. Donald was clean-cut, neatly dressed in khaki slacks and blue, long-sleeved chambray shirt. Gloria wore a dress that properly covered her knees. Her brown braids were swept back and piled in a bun.

  “Ah, fellow Mennonites,” I said, unable to suppress a smile.

  The Redigers smiled back. “We’ve come east to see the fall color,” Donald said.

  “But there doesn’t seem to be much,” Gloria said. It was a simple statement of fact, not a complaint.

  I shook my oversiz
ed noggin. “I’m sorry, folks, but we’ve had a dry summer and, well, to tell you the truth, you’re about ten days too early. Mid-October though, the mountainsides should be a blaze of color. I don’t suppose you’d care to stay until then.”

  Gloria shook her plain, but pretty head. Although she lacked a prayer cap—many modem Mennonites go without these days—the thick brown braids, gathered in back and held neatly in place with a myriad of simple hairpins, were a dead giveaway that she was of my faith.

  “I’m afraid a week is all we can afford,” she said softly. Her Hoosier accent was barely noticeable.

  I thought fast. I really didn’t need the money. My inn has done very well over the years, and despite a president with zipper problems, the economy has been good to me as well.

  “Tell you what, dears, I just happen to have a special plan called A.L.P.O.—Amish Liberals Partly Off. That’s you. You’re Mennonites, which is sort of like being liberal Amish, so you get partly off. Provided you clean your own rooms, of course.”

  The Redigers exchanged anxious glances. “Is that legal?” Donald asked.

  “Well—”

  “How much off?” Gloria asked.

  I strode casually from behind the check-in counter and peeked surreptitiously at her shoes. They were obviously not genuine leather, and had seen much better days.

  “Half off. That way you can stay the whole two weeks for the price of one.”

  The Redigers beamed, which in turn brought a smile to my face. I really do like it when my guests are happy. As to any accusations that I had just shown partiality—well, I did. And so be it. We all show partiality at some time or another. Anyone who disagrees with that is not being totally honest, and to me that’s a lot worse sin than showing favoritism. Even the Good Lord had a favorite disciple, for crying out loud. “God bless you,” Donald cried.

  “You are so kind,” Gloria said. “Half off! It is truly an answer to prayer.”

  I put a slender finger to my lips. “Shhh. The English will hear you.”

  By that I meant the pompous professor. The Amish, and some of the stricter Mennonites, refer to those outside the tradition as English. It is an appellation that has nothing to do with origin. Indeed, the Japanese are every bit as English to the Amish as are Londoners. In other words, English is our word for goyim.

  The Redigers knew exactly what I meant. They nodded their heads, and Gloria giggled nervously. I felt almost ebullient. It had been a long time since I’d had Mennonite guests—okay, to be truthful, these were my first Mennonite guests. Please understand, however, that we Mennonites are a simple people and not given to gallivanting needlessly around the country. At any rate, the ache in my bones that commenced with Professor Barnes’s appearance was gone. Things were looking up again.

  ***

  No sooner had I shown the grateful Redigers to their rooms when two real English guests showed up. Daphne and Edwina Moregold had written ahead from their home in Manchester, England, so they were expected. And since I have had real English guests before, I expected there would be some difficulty in communication (I shall hereby translate everything the Moregold sisters said for your edification). What I didn’t expect was a pair of identical twins.

  “Which one is which?” I asked gamely.

  The women, incidentally, appeared to be in their late fifties, early sixties. But given the English reputation for youthful, dewy complexions, and the fact that both were overweight, they might well have been a lot older.

  “I’m Edwina, the eldest,” one of the plump, pink-cheeked sisters said.

  “I’m Daphne, the youngest,” the other said.

  “Fat lot of good that does,” I wailed, and then mentally slapped myself for having used the F word in front of them.

  “I’ve got the beauty mark here. See?” Edwina, I think, pushed a lock of graying hair away from her convex forehead. A microscopic mole greeted my myopic eyes.

  “She’s far too proud of that thing if you ask me,” her sister said.

  I smiled pleasantly. “Then maybe she should display it.”

  “All right.” Edwina fished a rubber band (what the folks in Pittsburgh call a gum band) out of her purse, and pulled her shoulder-length hair back into a short, but revealing ponytail.

  What a difference a hairstyle makes. The two peas in a pod were now more like a bean and a pea. Sure, their bone structure remained the same, but now Daphne’s individual personality was on display along with her beauty mark.

  “Ah, that’s much better,” I said. “Now, if I recall correctly, you wrote to the Pennsylvania Tourist Bureau for accommodations in Amish country, and they sent you two a brochure. Have you two made up your minds yet about the A.L.P.O plan?”

  “We definitely want it,” Edwina said. “We wish to absorb as much American culture as possible.”

  “We’re thinking of retiring here,” Daphne explained.

  “Oh?”

  “Of course that won’t be for another thirty years, but it never hurts to plan ahead.”

  “At least thirty years,” Edwina said.

  I glanced down at the registration form. Call me nosy if you will, but I ask for more information than do other hostelries. At any rate, the twins were only twenty-nine. They both worked as machinists, making industrial-size bobbins for textile factories. Much to my surprise, I felt sorry for them.

  “The brochure contained several misprints,” I said. While lying is a sin, I’m quite sure some lies are not as bad as others. “You see, the brochure stated that guests would have to pay an extra twenty dollars a day for the privilege of cleaning their own rooms. What I meant to say is that I would deduct twenty dollars.”

  Edwina cleared her throat. “Is that twenty dollars off per day?”

  “Yes,” I heard these lips say.

  Two sets of identical green eyes sparkled. Daphne actually clapped her hands.

  “What lovely news,” she said. “Now we shall be able to see more of your wonderful country.”

  “Is it far to Disney World?” Edwina asked. She had pulled a pocket atlas from a purse and was thumbing through it. I saw Idaho and New Mexico flip by.

  I knew that the women had flown directly from London to Pittsburgh, where they’d rented a car. It takes me two hours to get to the Pittsburgh International Airport from Hernia, and I’ve been accused of having heavy feet—not lead feet, mind, just heavy feet. It seems to go with size eleven.

  “Did you think it was far from Pittsburgh?” I asked. They nodded vigorously in tandem, as if sharing only one short neck. “I remarked to Daphne that it was like driving halfway across England.”

  “Farther,” Daphne said. “Is Pennsylvania the largest state?”

  I smiled. “I’ve heard rumors that Texas is larger. As for Disney World, it’s fifteen times farther than Pittsburgh. You may want to fly.”

  The sisters looked crestfallen. “I’m afraid we can’t afford to,” Edwina said quietly.

  I skirted the counter once again and studied their shoes. Both pairs were sturdy leather, well-polished, but obviously very old.

  “Okay, you can have the room at half price and I’ll help you look for a supersaver.”

  They looked blank.

  “A cheap flight,” I said.

  Daphne brushed a stray wisp away from her beauty mark. “Are the hotels at Disney World expensive?”

  I gave them a pitying look. “Okay, scratch the A.L.P.O. I won’t charge you anything while you’re here.”

  They gasped simultaneously.

  “You mean we can stay for free?” Edwina said.

  I grimaced. “Please, dear, nothing in this world is ever really free. To the contrary. You will set and clear tables, wash dishes, and muck out the barn.”

  “The barn,” they chorused.

  I nodded. “I have a seventy-three-year-old pregnant Amish man doing it as we speak, but he really isn’t up to the task.”

  Both sets of green eyes blinked.

  “It’s a long story,
dears. Say, can either of you milk a cow?”

  They grinned. “Our granddad has a farm in Devonshire.”

  “Well, I just happen to have two cows who need milking on a twice daily basis. Their names are Matilda and Bessie.”

  “Super,” Edwina said. “Daphne here makes the best Devonshire cream—although it wouldn’t be proper Devonshire cream here, would it? Still, if clotted cream is what you’re after, Daphne is your woman.”

  Daphne beamed.

  “What is clotted cream?” I had the coarseness to ask.

  “Ah, that’s what rises to the top when you scald milk. It’s thicker, sweeter, and richer than whipped cream, and is delicious atop scones with jam.” She pronounced scones to rhyme with johns.

  “Do you make scones as well?” I asked, drooling only slightly.

  Daphne shook her head. “Edwina is the baker. Scones, tarts, you name it.”

  “I’d be happy to bake some for you, if Daphne will make her cream.”

  “It would be my pleasure,” Daphne said. “We could have a proper cream tea.”

  I hustled the twins up to their rooms before I got really carried away and offered them a salary.

  I am not easily shocked, having played hostess to half of Hollywood during my inn’s heyday. Trust me, there are those in that crowd who know no shame. One ingenue even bragged to me about breaking all ten of the commandments at once—only not in my inn, thank heavens. Still, before she checked out, I inspected her room for corpses and counted my best flatware. At any rate, I wasn’t so much shocked, but appalled, by my next two guests.

  She was tall and thin, approximately my age, but unlike me as brown as a hickory nut. Her color was related to her minority status which, incidentally, had nothing to do with race, but everything to do with a leisurely life in the sun. Vivian Mays was what my mama would have called “stinking rich.” It was a wonder she could even hold her head up, given the size and weight of the gold chains she wore draped around her neck.